One of the reasons I’ve become a conservative is because conservatives, generally speaking, have a healthier appreciation for history than the left. We believe institutions matter. We understand tradition has value. We don’t assume every generation is smarter than the one that came before it.
Read more The new censorship isn’t coming from the left—it’s coming from everyone
But every philosophy has a blind spot, and for conservatives, that blind spot is nostalgia. Somewhere along the way, parts of the conservative movement stopped defending America’s principles and started defending an imaginary version of America’s past. Those are two very different things.
As a Black conservative, I occasionally find myself in an awkward position. Progressives assume I spend my days apologizing for America’s history. Some conservatives assume I should pretend America’s rough edges were merely cosmetic. Neither assumption is true.
I don’t need America to have been perfect to believe she’s exceptional, and that’s actually the point.
The Left has turned history into a prosecutor. Every chapter is another exhibit for the case against America. Every flaw is proof the entire experiment was fraudulent. If you listened long enough, you’d think the United States contributed nothing to civilization except oppression.
That’s nonsense, but here’s the part conservatives sometimes miss: Responding with an equally sanitized version of history isn’t an answer. It’s just the mirror image of the same mistake. History isn’t a campaign commercial.
America produced the Declaration of Independence. It also tolerated slavery. It gave the world unprecedented constitutional liberty while millions of its own citizens were denied its full promise. Those truths are not mutually exclusive. Mature societies can hold both ideas in their heads without short-circuiting.
Unfortunately, social media has convinced us every historical conversation must end with someone screaming, “See! I told you!” Nuance has become the first casualty of the culture war. Somewhere, a historian just sighed and closed another browser tab.
The conservative argument has never been that America has no sins. Rather, the conservative argument is that America possesses the moral architecture to correct them. That’s a profound distinction.
The abolitionist movement didn’t emerge despite America’s founding ideals. It appealed to them. The Civil Rights Movement didn’t argue the Constitution was worthless. It argued America should finally live up to it. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. did not ask the nation to abandon the Declaration of Independence. He called it a promissory note that had yet to be fully honored.
That’s not anti-American; it’s deeply American.
As someone who grew up in Memphis, Tennessee, I know our history isn’t tidy. The city carries scars that are impossible to ignore, but it also produced extraordinary resilience, entrepreneurship, faith, music, and community. The lesson wasn’t that America failed beyond repair. The lesson was that imperfect people can build something better without pretending yesterday never happened.
That distinction matters because conservatives should never become curators of mythology.
Read more To SAVE America — or not?
If we begin defending America by airbrushing every uncomfortable chapter, we’ve already surrendered the intellectual high ground. We criticize the Left for rewriting history to fit modern ideology. We shouldn’t respond by rewriting it to make ourselves more comfortable.
Truth doesn’t require editing. In fact, truth is one of conservatism’s greatest strengths.
A confident nation doesn’t panic when someone points out historical failures. It acknowledges them, learns from them, and refuses to let them become the entire story. Likewise, a confident conservative shouldn’t feel compelled to defend every decision made by every previous generation simply because they lived under the same flag.
Conservatism is supposed to be about conserving principles—not embalming every historical moment in amber.
That’s why I often find myself telling fellow conservatives something that surprises them: you don’t have to lose the debate over America’s past to win the argument for America’s future.
The left often treats history as a prison sentence from which there can be no appeal. Some on the Right treat history like a family photo album where every picture is perfectly framed, and everyone smiled all the time.
Reality is better than either fantasy.
America is remarkable not because she never stumbled, but because she repeatedly found people willing to stand up, challenge injustice, and call the nation back to its founding principles. That story belongs to all Americans—including Black Americans whose sacrifices, faith, military service, entrepreneurship, and perseverance helped shape this country as surely as anyone else’s.
That isn’t grievance. That’s ownership.
I refuse to surrender my inheritance to people who insist America is irredeemable. I also refuse to pretend our history requires cosmetic surgery before it’s worthy of defending.
Patriotism doesn’t demand selective memory. Instead, it demands intellectual honesty.
If your love for America depends on pretending she never sinned, it isn’t patriotism—it’s nostalgia. And nostalgia has never written a Constitution, liberated a people, or built a stronger republic.
Read more The University of Michigan is now hiding grades from fragile freshman
The truth has.
Image created by George P. Brooks using AI.